ART & ANIMATION
Being a show of the "old school" the animation is consistent and is holding up decently, although it is a bit undistinguished. Sceneries are decorative and purposeful, but with little depth. I kept thinking of watercolor paintings.
The dystopian post-apocalyptic setting is somewhat lacking because of this, but for what is revealed storywise, ruins have stood derelict for quite some time.
However, the old subterranean complexes of lost, partially functioning machinery are refreshing highlights.
As for the mech / tech design there is nothing that has not been seen before, and done better for that matter.
Character animation is quite stilted, which is evident in the action sequences which are forgettable and don't amount to much.
Emotionally, the characters are reasonably well animated. The ones that are capable of expressing emotions, that is.
SOUND
The OP and ED are catchy and nice, but clash against the setting of the show.
The happy love theme of the OP is basically what you can expect from any generic show, and basically reflects the main protagonist's carefree nature. But the love theme is malplaced and leaves you wondering who she refers to.
As for the ED, this is even more obvious.
I was happy to see Kenji Kawai as composer for the score and soundtrack, though you do realise that it might not be some of his most inspired work.
STORY
Initially, there are some promising prospects surrounding the direction of the story as the group does their best to maintain their existance in the ruins of civilization.
This soon evolves down a convoluted tangent of utter plot convenience that boggles the mind.
The search for other human survivors is the main quest of the robots, as well as protecting and serving Haruka (which they are surprisingly inept at).
As everything revolves around Haruka, she conveniently wanders off unattended in ruins that should have been scouted and mapped from the get-go, just to stumble across things that will either kill her or move the story forward.
Throughout the series, misguided and ill-considered decisions are the bread and butter of the story progression.
The finale is too short and it feels that it was just wrapped up as quickly as possible, leaving a sour aftertaste.
Basically, the premise of this show is that friendship and love solves everything.
CHARACTERS
More or less all of the characters are stereotypes, in their most annoying form. A lot of the ing cast is atrociously uninspired and irritating.
As far as most of the robot's AI and character goes, they leave you wondering what jackass programmed them in the first place.
This is most evident in the case of Spike, who is a possessive manic-depressive and quite possibly some kind of failed sexaroid.
Character development is rudimentary, at best.
Except for the main characters (Haruka and Kanato) there is no backstory to any character except the hideously obvious Makoto Kusanagi-clone Angela.
Speaking of which; late in the series there is another clone from GitS.
VALUE
This series is rather forgettable, bringing nothing new to the table. Thus the re-watch value is basically non-existent.
Episodes are 15 minutes long, with 4 ½ minutes devoted to recap, OP, ED and trailer.
ENJOYMENT
Well, my review should make this section obvious. I enjoyed it to the point that I enjoyed not enjoying it.
That said, this show is best left unseen.
Explanation by spc on Thursday, 31.03.2011 01:23 e4l1y